Analytic Martial Arts

Monday, July 23, 2012

Studio X Post-Mortem

I've taken a new job, which means moving (yet again), which means I'll no longer be able to train at Studio X. This makes the third system I've studied, so I'm starting to get a feel for what I like/dislike in a studio. My history, briefly:

  • I started at USSD (many moons ago), which taught a contemporary synthesis of karate/kung-fu (heavy on the karate).
  • Later I studied Seven Start Praying Mantis at the Rochester Shaolin Academy.
  • Most recently I've been doing the pure kung-fu system (along with a little tai chi) they teach at Studio X.

So, things which I particularly liked about Studio X in comparison to other places where I've been a student:

  • Good warm-ups, based in part on the I Chin Ching. They've a basic routine for beginner's class and a more "invigorating" routine for advanced class (which regularly kicked my ass) which they stick to consistently. One of my big complaints about the other studios is that calisthenics tended to be "instructor's choice" and so often lacked any sort of rhyme or reason.
  • Padless sparring. Nothing teaches you to finally keep your hands closed quite like jamming your fingers for the gazillionth time. Not wearing gloves also allows you to practice a greater range of techniques. Compare with USSD, where sparring was done in full pads, or the Shaolin Academy, which didn't really do any sparring at all.

Moving on, things I disliked:

  • Low-quality feedback. One of the things that I liked about USSD was that I felt like I had an accurate picture of how I was doing. It might just have been the instructors I got to work with, but it felt like the standards of the school were high and praise was genuinely earned. I didn't get that same sense at Studio X.
  • The chief instructor put up with a tremendous amount of chatter in class; sometimes it was hard for her to get people's attention. That's probably symptomatic of the studio's highly-informal atmosphere, but it could be annoying at times.
  • Woo... woo... woo woo woo woo. There was a tremendous proliferation of woo and credulous repetition of MA apocrypha. I mostly just tuned it out, but I really wish that people would just knock it off already. Repeating the unsubstantiated feats of some grandmaster really doesn't serve any purpose.
  • Rigid, lockstep schedule. Once you got to brown belt everything was taught on a calendar-based schedule. This month is form X, next month it's form Y, you'll be testing on the material at the end of the quarter. This is more of a personal preference than a generic criticism; some people might benefit from that sort of organization. Didn't work out so hot for me because I traveled a lot for work and was perpetually trying to catch up.
  • Form-based curriculum. There wasn't a big emphasis on practical punching/kicking; we hardly spent any time at all working with pads. Which means I'm probably going to end up breaking my toes at the next studio until I learn how to pull them back again.

That's about it for Studio X. I've already identified Studio X+1; stay tuned for further adventures

Sunday, July 8, 2012

Studio X: Rank 3 Short Forms Revisited

Source: short_forms_rank_3.xml


Short forms required for promotion from Rank 3 to Rank 4. Each of these forms starts from natural stance and has "left" and "right" halves which are mirror images of each other. The right half, which usually begins with a right-sided attack, is always performed first, followed immediately by the left half.

Actions

  • BB: Bird Break
  • BF: Backfist
  • BS: Bow Stance
  • CS: Cat Stance
  • CSw: Circle Sweep
  • DBB: Downward Backfist Block
  • DPB: Downward Palm Block
  • G: Guard
  • HP: Horizontal Punch
  • HS: Horse Stance
  • IB: Inward Block
  • IntB: Intercepting Block
  • NS: Natural Stance
  • OB: Outward Block
  • RP: Reverse Punch
  • RSH: Rising Sidehand
  • SK: Snap Kick
  • TH: Twist Hit
  • UB: Upward Block
  • XB: Cross Block

Regions

  • C: Chin
  • G: Groin
  • LOW: Left Outer Wrist
  • ROW: Right Outer Wrist
  • T: Temple

Short Form 16

IntB
HP
HP
BS
↻
OB
HS<
HP→
IntB
↑↺

Right
NS
 
DBB
DBB
HP
IntB
BS
HP
OB
↺
←HP
HS>
↑↻
IntB

Left
DBB
DBB

Short Form 17

IntB
↑
HP
NS
↑
OB
BSHP
IntB
↑

Right
NS
 
HPBS
↑
IntB
NS
HP
OB
↑
HPBS
↑
IntB

Left
BSHP

Short Form 18

CSw
←DPB
C
↑
RSH
↮
LOW
⇈
BB
1
BSHP
IntB
↑

Right
NS
 
SK
CSw
C
↑
RSH
DPB→
↮
ROW
⇈
BB
HPBS
↑
IntB

Left
SK
2

1: This bird break serves multiple purposes. The immediate effect is to counter a grab of the performer's right wrist, but proper application also has the effect of a) pulling the attacker off-balance and/or forcing em to commit eir weight to eir front foot and b) turning the defender's torso to the left and bringing eir right hand to eir left hip. The defender can then uncoil to deliver a particularly effective rising sidehand.

2: Hands remain in guard position from the delivery of the sidehand through the delivery of the snap kick.

Short Form 19

BS
RP
↑
SK
CS
↻
UB
NS
BF→
DPB→
→
HS<
HP→
IntB
↑↺

Right
NS
 
TH
T
↑SK
G
BS
SK
↑
RP
CS
UB
↺
UB
←BF
NS
←
←DPB
←HP
HS>
↑↻
IntB

Left
T
↑SK
G
TH

Short Form 20

HP
IntB
BF
BSHP
IntB
↑

Right
NS
 
SKDBB
IntB
HP
BF
HPBS
↑
IntB

Left
DBBSK

Short Form 21

↓
UB
Bait
2
BS
↻
<
BF→G
XB
1
HS
IB
OB
⊙↓↺

Right
NS
 
CS
HP
UB
↓
Bait
2
BS
↺
G←BF
>
XB
1
IB
HS
⊙↓↻
OB

Left
HP
CS

1: Maintain outward block through this point. Inward and outward blocks should meet and form a transient cross-block.

2: Lean forward, leading with chin. The idea here is for the defender to bait the attacker into launching a strike at the defender's face.

Short Form 22

↑
UB
CS
←↻
IB
<
BF→G
XB
1
HS
IB
OB
⊙↑↺

Right
NS
 
BS
RP
2
UB
↑
CS
IB
→↺
>
G←BF
XB
1
IB
HS
⊙↑↺
OB

Left
RP
BS
2

1: Same thing as short form 21; transitory cross-block here.

2: One of the few times where it's appropriate to throw a reverse punch from bow stance.

Friday, June 29, 2012

Automated Typesetting For Analytic Martial Arts Notation

I've finally put together some code that makes it much easier to translate notation into HTML. I've used it to typeset a bunch of things already and it has greatly improved my efficiency in this regard. Briefly, here's how it works:

  • Techniques are collected into Analytic Martial Arts Notation (AMAN) documents. The documents are XML-based and optimized for hand-composition.
  • Each individual technique has a notation block which represents the notation proper.
  • The entire thing can be run through a set of typesetting scripts to produce HTML suitable for stand-alone publication or pasting into a blog.

Details of the document format and notation syntax follows.

Document Format

Here's a small sample document which execerises all the features I've developed to date:

<doc>
    <title>Title</title>
    <commentary>
        A Demonstration of the AMAN document format.
    </commentary>
    <actions>
        OB = Outward Block
        SK = Snap Kick
    </actions>
    <regions>
        T = Temple
        S = Stomach
    </regions>
    <definitions>
        <definition name="block_kick">
            SK,,
            OB,,
        </definition>
    </definitions>
    <techniques>
        <technique>
            <format columns="2"/>
            <englishname>Technique 1</englishname>
            <phonetic>TEK NEEK WUN</phonetic>
            <commentary>
                A technique demonstrating the features of AMAN.
            </commentary>
            <notation>
                RP,,,1
                block_kick
                ,"Bow",
            </notation>
            <notes>
                <note id="1">
                    Extended explanation of annotation 1.
                </note>
            </notes>
        </technique>
    </techniques>
</doc>

The document is enclosed in a single element, "<doc>" in this case, which is required for compatibility with XML::Parser. This outermost element is ignored and can be whatever suits your fancy. Each document has the following attributes:

  • title: A descriptive title.
  • commentary: An optional, free-form text string describing the overall contents of the document.
  • actions: A newline-separated block of <action symbol>/<description> pairs. This is one of the places where I've broken the XML standard a bit in order to make hand-composition easier.
  • regions: Like the actions element but contains <region>/<description> pairs. This element is optional since a collection of techniques may not make use of region specifiers.
  • definitions: An optional element enclosing one or more definition elements.
    • definition: The document may optionally include one or more definitions. These are named chunks of notation which can be interpolated into the techniques defined within the document. This feature is generally designed to assist with the transcription of longer forms which may have recurring sequences of moves.
  • techniques: Encloses one or more technique elements.

technique Elements

Each technique element describes one technique, where "technique" can be read as "sequence of moves which the author wants to group together for whatever reason". A technique may be as short or as long as necessary and has the following elements:

  • format: An optional directive use to pass formatting hints on to whatever typesetter you're using. The one which I've written, AMAN::HTMLFormatter, will produce a single column per notation block when columns equals 1, otherwise it produces a two-column, side-by-side layout.
  • commentary: An optional, free-form text string providing commentary on the technique.
  • notation: A block of AMAN; see description below.
  • notes: An optional element enclosing one or more note elements.
    • note: A free-form text string with associated ID. This was specifically developed as a footnoting mechanism with the ID referring back to one or more lines in the associated notation block via annotation column. However, there's no enforcement of this relationship, so this is a good place for general notes as well.

notation Elements

Each notation element contains a block of AMAN in a parser-friendly (and, hopefully, human-friendly) format. This block contains one or more lines, each of which has a left, center, and right portion separated by commas. A fourth column containing a text string may optionally be included to annotate the line.

Each section (left, center, and right) of a line is composed of 0 or more atoms. These atoms may be any of the following:

  • jump: A jump.
  • release: Instructs the performed to release eir grip on eir opponent/weapon.
  • A direction keyword indicating motion of the dan tien in the indicated direction. The direction keywords are: left, right, forward, back, forwardleft, forwardright, backleft, and backright.
  • look (<direction keyword>): Indicates the performer should focus eir attention on the indicated region.
  • <turnleft|turnright> [ ( <integer> ) ]: Denotes a left or right turn. An integer may optionall be included in parentheses following the keyword, indicating a turn of number degrees; 90° is assumed if this modifier is omitted.
  • "<literal string>": Indicates that a literal string should be inserted into the notation block at that location.
  • <action specifier> [ ( [ grapple|grip ] [ <diection keyword> ] [ <region specifier> ] ) ]: Describes a strike/block/grapple; most of the atoms in a technique will use this form. An arbitrary string of characters is assumed to be an action specifier if it is not a keyword or literal string. Each specifier may optionally be followed by a list of modifiers enclosed in parentheses:
    • grapple | grip: May be used to indicate that the action is a grapple or a weapon grip; a standard strike is assumed if these keywords are omitted.
    • <direction keyword>: Indicates the direction of application of the action. The default direction of application is assumed if no direction modifier is provided. Does not apply to grip actions.
    • <region specifier>: An aribtrary character string denoting a region.

A complete grammar with a more detailed description can be found in NotationParser.pm.

Getting Started

The code and more details on how it works can be found here. The easiest way to get an idea of how all this works in practice is to take a look at the posts where I've presented typeset material along with source files:

I hope this is useful to y'all; have fun.

Thursday, June 28, 2012

Studio X: Short Forms:Rank 2

Source: short_forms_rank_2.xml


This group of short forms is required for promotion from Rank 1 to Rank 2.

Actions

  • BF: Backfist
  • BS: Bow Stance
  • CS: Cat Stance
  • DBB: Downward Backfist Block
  • DBF: Downward Backfist
  • DE: Downward Elbow
  • DPB: Downward Palm Block
  • E: Elbow
  • FS: Front Sweep
  • G: Guard
  • HP: Horizontal Punch
  • HS: Horse Stance
  • IB: Inward Block
  • IFT: Inverted Finger Thrust
  • IS: Inward Smash
  • IntB: Intercepting Block
  • KT: Knee Trap
  • MG: Monkey Grab
  • MK: Mule Kick
  • NS: Natural Stance
  • OB: Outward Block
  • OS: Outward Smash
  • RBS: Reverse Bow Stance
  • RP: Reverse Punch
  • RSBK: Rising Side Blade Kick
  • S: Stomp
  • SB: Scoop Block
  • SK: Snap Kick
  • STK: Side Thrust Kick
  • TH: Twist Hit
  • UB: Upward Block
  • VP: Vertical Punch
  • VSH: Vertical Sidehand

Regions

  • C: Chin
  • LIF: Left Inner Forearm
  • LIW: Left Inner Wrist
  • T: Temple

Short Forms 6 - 10

Short forms 6 through 10 are performed in an unbroken sequence like short forms 1 - 5.

↖
SK

Short Form 8
BS
HP
1
↑

Transition
SK
4
DPBBS
UB
↮
↮
FS
LIF
⇈
MG
LIW
⇈
MG
3
IB
OB

Short Form 7
HP
BS
1
↑

Transition
TH
T
SK↑
G
IntB
HP
BFBS
2
SBRBS
TH
T
↑
G
T
↑
G
TH
HP
IntB

Short Form 6
BS
HP
1
 
←VP
HS
←↻
CS
6
←OB
→↺
←VP
HS
←↻
CS
6
←IB
→↺

Short Form 10
←VP
HS>
UB
5
↻
MK
↓
NS
STK
↘
SK
↗
↖
SK

Short Form 9
BS
HP
1
OB
↺180
E
↓
BS
↓
STK
↙
⌝
↺180
SK
↗

1: Not actually a horizontal punch; hand is held out as though a punch had just been thrown.

2: The twist hit, scooping block, and backfist should be strung together in one smooth, circular motion. The transition from bow stance to reverse bow and back to bow stance should match the timing of the strikes.

3: Pivot right foot outward in preparation for front sweep.

4: Maintain blocks while performing kick.

5: Not actually a vertical punch; hand is held out as though a punch had just been thrown. Maintain upward block throughout short form 10.

6: Transitory cat.

Short Form 11

SK
RP
RP
SK
SK
RP
OB
NS

Short Form 12

BS
↻180
BS
↑
SKDBB
S
DBF
DE
RP
↻180
VSHBS
E
↓
↓
NS

Short Form 13

T
↑
G
IFT
1
BS
↑
SK
IS
RBS
↓
NS

1: Guard is open-handed in this case.

Short Form 14

C
↑
RSBK
OS
RBS
↓
NS

Short Form 15

STK
↮
↮
↑
KT
3
BS
↑
FS
2
LIF
⇈
MG
LIW
⇈
MG
1
IB
OB
BS
↑
NS

1: Turn right foot out in preparation for front sweep.

2: Remainder of technique assumes that defender pulls lead foot up and doges sweep.

3: The sweep missed, so step forward and pull the attacker into the knee trap.